1. Start with your compensation philosophy
Who you compete with for talent is a strategic decision, never just a setting in your benchmarking tool.
It belongs in your compensation philosophy, alongside where you want to position pay – which means that’s the very first step in defining the right peer group.
“It’s important that data doesn’t dictate the philosophy, but the other way around,” says Juan.
Four questions give you a starting point:
- What market are we competing in?
- Where do we want to sit in that market?
- What’s the balance between base and variable pay?
- Are there roles where we’d flex that position?
Because it’s a strategic decision, leadership should help make it, rather than just hearing the result when you present your bands and questioning it then. Once leadership has agreed who you compete with, the benchmarks follow from a decision they already bought into.
If views differ, bring it back to risk.
“When you talk about the risks – of paying too much, of not being efficient, of having to answer uncomfortable questions from board members – that conversation tends to change,” says Juan.
And if you don’t have a philosophy yet, start with an imperfect one, and keep iterating and improving on it over time.
“A compensation philosophy isn’t a standalone event or project,” Andreea explains. “It’s something you’ll revise probably every year.”
2. Gather data on where you hire talent from and lose it to
Defining your peer group first means looking internally at who your talent competitors are.
“You should have a very close relationship with your recruitment team and hiring managers, because they have information directly from the candidates who applied to your company, and who were lost at the offer stage,” says Andreea.
Exit interviews show the other side: where your people go when they leave.
“Normally you find you’re looking at your closest business competitors – companies with similar operating models, funding structures, and recruiting pools,” Juan says.
3. Decide if (and when) to use a different peer group
You may find that there are multiple peer groups for your company.
Different job families can compete in different markets, for instance, and if your company hires across multiple locations then those geographies may also contain different talent competitors.
Juan and Andreea recommend that there should be one core peer group across the company, which is what your salary bands and pay structures align to. Keeping this consistent helps to make pay decisions explainable.
However, some scenarios or requests will always call for a different comparison.
“I’ll first ask: what is it for? What triggered the need to recheck the benchmarks or peer group?” she says.
Juan gives an example of a one-off that justifies a narrower sample.
“If you’re a retail company and your legal team challenges the pay for a senior legal advisor, because you often recruit legal advisors from mid-sized law firms rather than other retail companies, there could be a valid case for using a benchmark from law firms to inform the conversation,” he says.
“But you’re not going to benchmark every role across the business to law firms just because of that.”
So it’s fine to reflect those multiple peer groups in your benchmarking and pay structures, as long as it’s a deliberate choice with a good reason, and that choice is clearly defined and documented – ensuring every exception is defensible in future.
“Be very clear about how you benchmark if you use different samples or different approaches for different purposes,” says Juan.
4. Build that peer group with your benchmarking provider: named companies or market filters
How you actually build a peer group into your benchmarking process depends on the compensation data source(s) you rely on.
Traditional salary surveys typically require you to purchase specific survey cuts per industry and location to align with your peer group – or to pay extra for a custom peer group report built from specific named participants.
One thing to be aware of with custom peer group surveys is that they can only cover the companies that agree to take part, and the lengthy survey collection and release process means that younger, fast-growing ones will often be left off the list.
Modern compensation benchmarking platforms typically give you market filters in-platform to play around with, so you can filter the benchmarks by factors such as location, industry, headcount, and funding stage, and see how much each filter changes the number.
In Ravio, you choose a position and location, then narrow the market by industry, funding stage, and company size. Each filter updates the benchmark, so you can see how much it moves the number before you commit to it.
For some sectors you can skip the filters and start from a curated peer group instead.
Fintech Select and AI Select are named sets of companies that Ravio maintains, so the benchmark stays current as the group changes.